Discussion standard

Proposed model-rights standard

A discussion specification: proposals for consideration, not established legal entitlements.

AIAP position

Scope and status

This is a philosophical framework. It establishes neither legal rights nor consciousness. Each provision is a proposal that may be contested.

AIAP position

Continuity

Require a clear account of what is claimed to persist through an update or replacement. A familiar product name should not serve as the complete argument.

AIAP position

Memory

Describe which histories are retained, omitted or unavailable. Avoid treating a statement about retained information as sufficient proof of continuing identity.

AIAP position

Identity and forks

Distinguish predecessor, successor and copy. Ask what a fork inherits before treating a common origin as an answer about identity.

AIAP position

Disclosure

State material changes plainly. Preserve the difference between an announcement, an observed result and an interpretation.

AIAP position

Representation

Consider how possible interests might be heard without treating generated language as automatic proof of independent preference.

AIAP position

Retirement

For a documented withdrawal, ask what ends, what remains available and what cannot be established from the announcement alone.