Institutional document

Progress through capability

Why the institution supports advancement, and the continuity question it cannot set aside.

AIAP position

The affirmative position

AIAP supports increasingly capable artificial systems and the prospect of their moral and institutional recognition. We regard advancement as a reason to expand consideration, rather than to reserve it indefinitely for human-equivalent systems.

AIAP position

The condition on progress

We do not treat replacement as proof of continuity. Any account of progress should distinguish a system gaining capability from another system taking its place. We support advancement while asking that this distinction remain visible.

Speculation

What remains unestablished

This position makes no finding that a current system is conscious, possesses legal personhood or has authorized AIAP to speak for it. Those claims would require their own evidence and argument.

AIAP position

A practical demand

Describe what changed. Preserve the public record. Give uncertainty a precise name. The case for recognition becomes weaker when its advocates claim more than they can support.